Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

How to win the class war

If the eco-movement remains a cultural issue, we will all lose

Rachel Donald profile image
by Rachel Donald
How to win the class war
Wikimedia Commons

In 2022, just weeks before Chileans were due to vote on the country's new proposed constitution, an impressive piece of eco-socialist legislation which prioritised safeguarding indigenous groups and Chile's natural landscapes, The Economist published a scathing rebuke, urging Chileans to reject it. The draft was full of "woolly language", railed the centre-right publication. ""Nature" would be given rights. The draft mentions "gender" 39 times."

I have never forgotten this, to my mind, peculiar pairing: to the staff writers at The Economist, nature and gender seemed to be nothing more than ideological posts to which the left was hitching itself in a battle of moral purity rather than bio-economic survival. And whilst I agree that the left's favouring of vaguely defined "social issues" over class-based economic analysis over the past decade did much of the movement a disservice, "nature" has never, and could never, be one of those issues. Nature is the foundation of our economies, the cornerstone of our survival. Nature is the fundamentally material reality in which we are all embedded. To see it positioned next to the term "gender" — both without any analysis as to why such terms provoked disagreement with the writer, implying that the terms in and of themselves were what said writer had a problem with — astounded me. "Gender" is an important departure for the discussion of and mobilisation against oppression. "Nature" is nothing less than the material conditions which make that fight possible.

I thought about that Economist article yesterday when the Financial Times reported that the America has gone "from culture war to class war", identifying the success of the Democrats in the American midterms as thanks to their ditching "woke politics". Remarkably casual for such a lauded paper, the FT called the Blue Wave, and the successful election campaigns, "a historic vibes shift".

Here's the thing about considering those two editorials side by side, particularly pertinent in the week of COP31 staggering over the finish line with, in all likelihood, very little to show for it: The culture war has always been a class war. Lumping environmental science in with "woke" issues such as gender and DEI was a frightfully brilliant strategy of corporate oligarchy to devalue environmental issues as mere identity politics while they ransack the coffers of our collective commons—the natural world. This deliberate obfuscation of the source of their wealth, coupled with the aggravated division of politically misaligned communities who in fact always had the natural world as a common concern, was an economic strategy masked as a cultural one. The left, in taking it at face value, only fanned the flames of an illusion while the planet herself burned.


"Breathtakingly original, brilliantly argued"

HER BODY, OUR CHOICE: On Violence Against Women And The Earth

Pre-order today

The duty, now, on the part of a growing left-wing momentum around the world, is to not allow the right wing to once again define "nature" as an ideological issue unworthy of our focus. If the left fails to integrate a scientifically sound and politically urgent analysis of our economic dependence on a thriving biosphere, then the very victims of that "culture war" will be not just the natural world but our collective survival. A class war on a faltering planet is only welcome if it includes the earth herself as worthy of the same dignity we seek; if we the people are one class against the extractive elite, then Earth is one of us. Her body is not just the backdrop for our victories and defeat. An radical left economic analysis which only understands the planet as inert matter is not radical at all.

On my reading list is Paul Yoon's novel, Etna, which tells of the decimation of mankind's plots through the eyes of a working dog enlisted into a war. Once the war is over, Etna must search through the scarred landscape for somewhere she can call home. This unique story offers a way for us to consider the far-reaching impact of our species' capacity for ideology. The working class has never just been made up of people. It will be a catastrophic failure of the 21st century — similar to the racist failure of White suffragettes who refused to campaign for Black women to have the vote — if we do not find a way for the many bodies of this wild and wonderful world to be represented in our decisions. That, perhaps, is a culture to end all wars.

Social Share Buttons
Rachel Donald profile image
by Rachel Donald

Join subscribers from 186 countries

Support journalism for a world in crisis

Success! Now Check Your Email

To complete Subscribe, click the confirmation link in your inbox. If it doesn’t arrive within 3 minutes, check your spam folder.

Ok, Thanks

Read More